We finally made it out to D’Agostino’s in Niles on a Friday night with the whole family, and it was long overdue. We’d been going to the Glenview location for years before it closed, and once that one shut down we sort of fell out of the habit of making the trip. Glad we broke that streak.
D’Agostino’s Niles at a Glance
- Where: 7530 W Oakton St, Niles, IL
- Price: $$ (mozzarella sticks $10.99, $6 at happy hour)
- Vibe: Big dining room, a real bar, and a sizable patio
- Order: Personal thin crust pepperoni pizza
- Skip: Mozzarella sticks at full price, wait for happy hour
- Good for: Families, happy hour, thin crust and sweet sauce people
The Space
We were not expecting this. The Niles location is big. Like, genuinely, surprisingly big. There’s a large dining room, a full bar that actually looked like a bar people hang out at, and a sizable outdoor patio that we’re going to have to come back for when the weather is actually on our side. The night we went it was a little too cold to eat outside, but the patio setup looked great and it’s already on the list for a warmer visit.
What also made the night feel different from what we were used to at the old Glenview location: there were actually people here. A full Friday night crowd, tables occupied, some action at the bar. The Glenview spot always had this thing where we felt like we were the only ones dining in, which wasn’t a bad thing, but it’s just nice when a place has some energy. Service kept up fine with the room, nobody felt ignored, and we never felt like they were trying to rush us out. Good pacing all around.
Mozzarella Sticks

We started with the mozzarella sticks, which came out in a little basket lined with wax paper and a side cup of marinara. Six sticks, $10.99 on the regular menu. Now look, almost $11 for six mozzarella sticks is a number that makes me pause every single time. Thankfully it was happy hour, so we got them for $6, which is where they belong.
Are they frozen? Almost certainly. Are they the same frozen mozz sticks you’d get at half the restaurants in the suburbs? Probably. But the breading was golden and had a solid crunch, and the cheese pulls were right where they needed to be. They did the job. At $6 during happy hour, easy recommend. At $11, I’d still order them and be mildly annoyed about it. If happy hour deals matter to your planning, check out our thoughts on Pinstripes Northbrook’s happy hour too.
Personal Thin Pepperoni Pizza

Nobody else at the table wanted pizza. My daughter was actually upset we didn’t go to Olive Garden. So I was the only one at the table excited about the fact that we were at a pizza place, which is fine, I’ll take the whole personal pie for myself.
The pizza came out looking exactly like I remembered it: razor-thin crust, deep red sauce peeking out from under a solid blanket of melted cheese, pepperoni crisped up at the edges. This is the pizza. The sweet sauce is the whole thing at D’Agostino’s, and if you’re not into a sweeter tomato sauce this place might not be for you. But if you are, it hits exactly the way it’s supposed to. The crust had a good snap to it, the cheese-to-sauce ratio was on point, and the portions on the personal size were actually solid. Sometimes personal pizzas taste like a totally different, lesser product. This one tasted like the real thing. I’d been too long without it and it reminded me why this place is one of my favorite pizza spots in the area.
Order this. Don’t share it. And if you’re a pizza fan looking for more spots in the city, our Parlor Pizza Bar review is worth a read.
Chicken Alfredo

My wife went with the chicken alfredo, which came out as a big bowl of fettuccine in a creamy white sauce, loaded with chicken and wilted greens, and two pieces of toasted bread tucked in on the side. The portion was genuinely large. She enjoyed it, but in hindsight she probably should have split it with our daughter instead of us getting her a separate plate. She ended up boxing half of it for lunch the next day, which is never a bad outcome.
It’s not going to change your life. It’s chicken alfredo at a pizza place. But the sauce was creamy and well-seasoned, the chicken was tender, and it held up well enough that the leftovers were still good the next day. If your table is split between pasta and pizza, go with the pizza. But the alfredo is a solid call if that’s what you’re after.
Kids Pasta Alfredo

Our daughter wanted pasta with alfredo sauce, which technically isn’t on the kids menu. The kids menu has pasta, just not with alfredo. She asked for it anyway, and to their credit the staff made it happen without any fuss. It came out in a fun little spoon-shaped dish, just a simple pile of fettuccine in a creamy alfredo, which she was very happy about. High praise from a kid who would have rather been at Olive Garden.
The fact that they were willing to accommodate the off-menu request without making a whole thing of it says something. Good look from the kitchen.
Chicken Wings

My son got the wings, plain, with BBQ sauce on the side. He’s in a wings phase right now and he put down a whole plate without much trouble. They came out golden brown and cooked through, no sauce on them, with a side cup of BBQ. He wasn’t into the BBQ sauce, but he’s particular about sauces in general. I tried it and thought it was fine, nothing that’s going to make you reconsider barbecue sauce as a concept, just a solid, straightforward BBQ. The wings themselves were the real win here, good texture, nothing greasy or overdone.
Overall
D’Agostino’s is one of those places that isn’t trying to be anything other than what it is, and that consistency is exactly why I keep coming back to it. The pizza is not going to blow anyone’s mind if you’ve never been into the sweeter sauce style, but if that’s your thing, this is one of the better versions of it you’re going to find in the suburbs. The Niles location specifically surprised us with how much space there is and how lively it felt on a Friday night. We’ll definitely be back, and next time we’re sitting on that patio. Go hungry, order the pizza, and hit happy hour if you can.
If you’re in the Niles area and looking for more dining options, check out our reviews of Kouklas Greek Eatery and bb.q Chicken, both worth a visit.
AntiFoodie Rating: 8.5/10
D’Agostino’s FAQ
What is D’Agostino’s pizza like?
Razor-thin crust with a deep red, noticeably sweet tomato sauce. The sweet sauce is the whole thing at D’Agostino’s, so if you are not into a sweeter sauce this place might not be for you.
What should I order at D’Agostino’s in Niles?
The personal thin pepperoni pizza. The crust has a good snap, the cheese to sauce ratio is on point, and the personal size tastes like the real thing rather than a lesser product.
Does D’Agostino’s in Niles have outdoor seating?
Yes, there is a sizable outdoor patio, and it is worth planning around when the weather cooperates.
Does D’Agostino’s have a happy hour?
Yes. The mozzarella sticks drop from $10.99 to $6, which is where they belong.
Is D’Agostino’s in Niles good for families?
Yes. The Niles location is surprisingly big with a large dining room, and there is a kids pasta option on the menu.
