A Picky Eater in the Chicago Food Scene

Matey’s Bar Review (Michigan City, IN): Beachy Vibes, Glass in the Ice

We tried Matey’s Bar and Restaurant in Michigan City for a family dinner on the kid-friendly patio. The food was solid bar fare, but a piece of glass in the kids’ ice bin left a mark on the night.

By Tom · September 1, 2026 · 10 min read

Matey’s Bar Review (Michigan City, IN): Beachy Vibes, Glass in the Ice

Restaurants

The Hand & The Eye Chicago Review: Magic, Dinner, Verdict

Shoreline Brewery Review (Michigan City, IN): The Nachos Steal the Show

Drift on Pine Review (LaPorte, IN): The Smashburger Is the Move

Browse by Food Type

More Posts

Electric Shuffle and RPM Steak Review (River North, Chicago): Shuffleboard, Seafood Towers, and a $29 Burger

D’Agostino’s Pizza Review (Niles, IL): Sweet Sauce, Thin Crust, and a Patio Worth Coming Back For

Restaurant Reservations – Do You Still Have to Wait?

Bluestone Bar and Grill Review (Evanston, IL): A Neighborhood Classic Worth Revisiting

Pinstripes Northbrook Review: Happy Hour and Bocce Under New Ownership

Kouklas Greek Eatery Review (Niles, IL): What We Ordered and What We’d Get Again